1,500 blown off confidential Oklahoma Tax Commission (OTC) Emails that tripped up cover-up.

Like the 1,000s of other pages of evidence uncovered and descriptions of crimes on this site, this web page is only one part of a massive multi-state entanglement of government corruption and cover-up. See size

Background

1,500 Confidential Oklahoma Tax Commission (OTC) emails obtained April 2010 dated (Nov 2008 - Apr 2010) exposed: the following and tripped up the tax revenue theft cover-up. Note the 1,500 emails involved only five ⁽¹²⁾ of Oklahoma's sixty-three different hidden tax credit types, three tax refund types, and one four year period 2006-2009. ⁽¹⁶⁾

Part of what was exposed included:

Subject		Link
Re: Timelines provide circumstances.		View
This is a massive case of economic development fraud, other forms of financial, and banker's crimes, and crimes to cover-up. All this entangled with other groups and a variety of crimes in other states.
$220 million tax revenue theft, where OTC swapped counterfeit 2006 tax credits for gross production tax refunds. OTC did not report any of this, and more, as required by law. Note the two-year delay and lost interest on $220 million.		View
The 1,500 emails dated (Nov 2008 - Apr 2010) involved only five ⁽¹⁾ of Oklahoma's sixty-three different hidden tax credits, three tax refund types, and one four year period 2006-2009.		View
Multiple uses of the same tax credits.
More evidence of 2006 cover-up.
Key emails and "Confidential Tax Letter Rulings'		View
IRC CAPCOs Reports 2006 to 09.
Five tax credit types $185 million tax credits & $220 million GP tax refunds.
Nine tax credit types were used by insurance companies to avoid/evade paying $430 million in Insurance Premiums taxes.		View
That covers 3 of 4 ways state law allows counterfeit tax credits to be laundered other than used to evade paying state income taxes.

Key OTC employees questioning claims, but ignored! View

Still, covered-up is what happened with the 2006 tax credits during the years 2007, 2008, 2009, and 2010. Still covered-up!

Circa Dates	Subject	Link
	The scams
3/9/2006	Oklahoma tax credit abuse controversy. $221 million false investment Claim Altus Venture & Affinity Ventures in Quartz Mountain Aerospace (QMA) formerly Luscombe Aircraft (LAC) (All FSB Altus OK subsidiaries). OTC forms 526 & 526A.
March 2006	FSB & Altus Venture were setting up a separate but different scam in Colorado
10/31/2006	60 more CFIA tax revenue theft claims, and would total 290 claims by 2009.
	OTC emails would prove
2006 to Jul 2009	Multiple uses of the same counterfeit 2006 tax credits, e.g., Altus Venture and Chaparral Energy.	View
Nov 2008 to Jul 2009	OTC was swapping counterfeit 2006 SBV and RSBV tax credits for gross production tax refund checks, and there were major problems.
Nov 2008 to Jul 2009	Altus Venture, Affinity Ventures, Chaparral, and related subs received $108 million of $220 million theft.
	OTC problems
	Tax credits were not documented, no records were kept for tax credits used. This triggered a later attempt by auditors to document and the auditors were restricted by Tony Mastin, the OTC Executive Director.
	Oklahoma did not have enough GP tax revenue to pay the refunds. Re: the largest drop in oil price history, 70%, occurred from July to November 2008. They had to steal from other budgeted items.

4/25/2010	OTC emails that tripped-up, cover-up (2006-2020) and when combined with other evidence uncovered revealed:
2/22/2010	First of 1,500 OTC emails (required two months to copy). $220 million payouts in OTC emails dated Jan - Jul 2009, the same period the Altus bank was under investigation for crimes in Colorado. OTC employees were forced to do the leadership's dirty work. Note: Some of the 2006 tax credits were sold at half price and used as tax credits. Starting early 2007, $135 million in tax credits was filed with claims to swap for tax refunds and stored someplace inboxes. These boxes mysteriously appeared at OTC when QMA prematurely failed in Nov 2008, requiring recapturing by law.

12/11/2008	Four Boxes of Tax Refund claims & complexities	View
11/19/2008	Earliest GP Tax Refund Claim	View
1/1/2009	Bogus tax credit investment claims 2006 & 2007. OTC Form 526	View
	Unqualified claims
1/6/2009	Proof of using ineligible receipts. GP Tax refunds 1608 oldest Mar 07 and receipts out of date	View
	Other issues OTC employees encountered with tax credit claims. A number of requirements were not met, disqualifying claims.
	* A different set of names than the claimed original investors. Only the original investors were eligible.
	* Only those who had paid gross production taxes were eligible. Some had not.
	* Dates on paid gross production tax receipts disqualified many.

	Other issues
	In other tax credit cases business investments failed for lack of funding before the ink dried. Re: the Liquidity Event.

2/22/2009	Oklahoma budget shortfall estimate hits $900 million	View

OTC's failure to document tax credit claims and keep records of tax credits used. Employees coerced..
03-30-09	* OTC Employees unable to find any documentation of records told to skip (pre) auditing & rush payment.	View
04/21/2009	* Later OTC employees were told they would have to justify denying claims.	View.

After cover-up.
Corruption worse after cover-up BOK, Foxborough & WPG exposed evidence by advertising $3 for $1 tax credits.
12/31/2009	Bank of Oklahoma's (BOK) and Foxborough's claims filed after 2009 cover-up, and triggered FBI's threats.	View.

	Corrupted Openbooks not reported until after the 2009 cover-up
2006 - 09	16,000 hidden users of $3 billion tax credits and tax refunds for 15 of Oklahoma's 63 tax credit and three tax refund types, for one four-year period 2006 thru 2009.	View
1/15/2009	Then only reporting 8% when first launched a year late. 205.6 Internet List of Taxpayers Who Claim or May Claim Any Tax Credit. State lawmakers. Openbooks created to give a false sense of security	View

1/15/2009	Openbooks was not reported until after the FBI cover-up. Openbooks first launched a year late, with more than 90% of the tax credits missing, and remains corrupted at every angle. Dates, names, types, the mere 4% of some tax credits, 0% of other tax credits, and tax refunds amounts.

	FBI tripped up and started threats to silence reporting evidence of FBI's role in covering-up organized crime and election funding fraud.

	Oklahoma Tax Commission Tax Expenditure Reports (TER)
	Tax Expenditure Reports are bi-annual estimates that were not even close. With some tax credits, estimates were only about 2% of the actual tax credits.
1/1/2006	2005-2006	View
1/1/2008	2007-2008	View
1/1/2010	2009-2010	View
	More contradictions: Both TERs and the first Openbooks tax credit report Jan 2009 Datagov, reported less than 10% of actual tax credits used.